Protection of Conscience Project
Protection of Conscience Project
Service, not Servitude

Service, not Servitude

Is abortion for Down Syndrome ‘eugenics’?

BioEdge, 31 January, 2021
Reproduced under Creative Commons Licence*


Michael Cook*

Aborting a child because tests show that he will have Down Syndrome is often described by its opponents as “eugenics”. This is fiercely contested. For instance, Mark Joseph Stern, a columnist for Slate, describes this idea as “both illogical and totally detached from reality”.

“Eugenics is the systematic elimination of specific people to alter the human gene pool. … There is no evidence that Americans who terminate pregnancies due to Down syndrome are seeking to systematically eliminate those with the condition from the face of the planet.”

This is a reasonably common idea to defend the decisions of women who choose abortion rather than raise a child with Down Syndrome.

So it’s interesting to counterpoise the opinion of doctors who disagree. Here is Richard Gunderman, a distinguished radiologist at Indiana University, writing in Psychology Today.

Yet those who opt to test and decide to terminate should be clear on one thing: They are tinkering with who is born and who isn’t, and they are doing so based on genes. My wife and I faced a similar choice when we had a child in our 40s, electing not to test. In some cases of Down syndrome, such a life would have been marked by severe disability and early death, but in other cases, the outcome might have been quite different.

The point is not that parents facing perhaps the most difficult decision of their lives should be branded eugenicists, but simply to indicate that despite protests to the contrary, eugenics has not been fully consigned to history’s dustbin. As a society, we are still deciding who is and is not born based on genes, and the decisions we make shape humanity not just into the next generation, but generations to come.

This article is published by Michael Cook and BioEdge under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation to BioEdge. Commercial media must contact BioEdge for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.